Culinary Crimes
Culinary Crimes
TV ShowReturning Series

Culinary Crimes

2023
4 seasons
54 episodes
CrimeMysteryComedy

In Culinary Crimes, Courtney and a rotating cast of 2 Smosh Family members (and an occasional guest) try to deduce changes made to 3 dishes that were picked out from various sources on the internet. They must read the briefing, see the crime scene, guess the swaps, and then give appropriate punishments to whoever proposed the changes.

What critics are saying

Verdicts use the same scale as your list: highly recommended through avoid — plus optional scores and blurbs.

Highly recommended Recommend Give it a go Neutral Avoid

Nobody on Critic, Sir! has logged a verdict for this title yet. The silence is either respectful or suspicious.

Sign in and use Add to My List below to share your own verdict.

Cast

Seasons

In Culinary Crimes, Courtney and a rotating cast of 2 Smosh Family members (and an occasional guest) try to deduce changes made to 3 dishes that were picked out from various sources on the internet. They must read the briefing, see the crime scene, guess the swaps, and then give appropriate punishments to whoever proposed the changes.

  • Can You Guess What's Wrong With This?

    1.Can You Guess What's Wrong With This?

    09-11-202336 min

    On the internet, people in the comments of recipes are committing culinary crimes EVERY. DAY. Detective Courtney Miller is on the case to help investigate them.

  • Should This Pasta Be Illegal?

    2.Should This Pasta Be Illegal?

    07-12-202334 min

    Angela's pasta skills are put to the ultimate test.

  • Unsolved Culinary Crimes

    3.Unsolved Culinary Crimes

    26-12-202331 min

    We need JUSTICE in these recipe comments!

  • What's Wrong With This Soup?

    4.What's Wrong With This Soup?

    06-02-202434 min

    What crimes were committed in these vegan and gluten-free recipes? The experts, Ian and Anthony, are here to help us figure it out.

  • We Tried the Worst Recipes on Reddit

    5.We Tried the Worst Recipes on Reddit

    05-03-202438 min

    Ms. Italian herself is here to crack the case of these CRIMES of culinary origin.

  • Something Is Wrong With This Junk Food...

    6.Something Is Wrong With This Junk Food...

    02-04-202431 min

    Pizza, wings, and a brownie? What could go wrong?

  • These Ingredients Should NEVER Be Swapped!

    7.These Ingredients Should NEVER Be Swapped!

    30-04-202435 min

    It's dinner time and what's on the menu? JUSTICE!

  • Professional Chef Brad Leone Solves Culinary Crimes

    8.Professional Chef Brad Leone Solves Culinary Crimes

    04-06-202437 min

    BRAD LEONE is here to solve the crimes of culinary!

  • Professional Detective Solves Culinary Crimes

    9.Professional Detective Solves Culinary Crimes

    09-07-202431 min

    The best detective in the WORLD is here to solve culinary crimes.

  • The Most Cursed Ingredient Swaps

    10.The Most Cursed Ingredient Swaps

    06-08-202438 min

    Some REAL weirdos making up recipes out there

  • Messed Up Grandma Recipes

    11.Messed Up Grandma Recipes

    03-09-202433 min

    Sometimes Grandma's cooking does NOT hit the spot...

  • Can We Spot The Difference In These Recipes?

    12.Can We Spot The Difference In These Recipes?

    01-10-202448 min

    bbno$ picks up his badge to help us solve these CULINARY CRIMES!

  • The Scariest Ingredient Swaps

    13.The Scariest Ingredient Swaps

    29-10-202444 min

    Jordan Myrick is here to solve these spooky scary substitutes!

  • They Put FISH In The Thanksgiving Stuffing?

    14.They Put FISH In The Thanksgiving Stuffing?

    26-11-202434 min

    Sometimes a recipe is more of a guideline...FOR CRIMINALS

  • Who Put KETCHUP In Santa's Cookies?

    15.Who Put KETCHUP In Santa's Cookies?

    24-12-202445 min

    If there's one thing Santa knows, it's cookies.

  • Someone Put Lucky Charms In The Dip?

    16.Someone Put Lucky Charms In The Dip?

    11-02-202546 min

    We specifically said DON'T mess with Texas...and they did.

  • Gatorade? In My Linguine?

    17.Gatorade? In My Linguine?

    11-03-202545 min

    NO. It is NOT the same thing.

  • Carrot Cake vs. Kale Cake?

    18.Carrot Cake vs. Kale Cake?

    08-04-202538 min

    These vintage recipes should stay in the past.

  • Can We Taste The Pepper In These Pancakes?

    19.Can We Taste The Pepper In These Pancakes?

    13-05-202542 min

    No time to wait until Saturday, GET YOUR PANCAKES OUT it's Culinary Crimes!

  • Can We Guess These Party Food Fouls?

    20.Can We Guess These Party Food Fouls?

    10-06-202538 min

    It's my party and I'll cry if I want to...and these recipes make me want to.

  • Can We Guess What's Wrong With These Fair Foods?

    21.Can We Guess What's Wrong With These Fair Foods?

    15-07-202542 min

    FAIR FOOD! But are these recipe changes fair or not? We will be the judge!

  • Can We Guess The Secret Ingredient?

    22.Can We Guess The Secret Ingredient?

    26-08-202533 min

    Taters or traitors? To spud or no to spud?

  • Which Dish Is The MOST Criminal?

    23.Which Dish Is The MOST Criminal?

    30-09-202533 min

    Thanks to FLVR for sponsoring this video.

  • Not So Happy Holiday Mashup

    24.Not So Happy Holiday Mashup

    03-12-202545 min

    Tis the season for JUSTICE

  • Cheers to Crime

    25.Cheers to Crime

    13-01-2026

    We are so back, hello 2026!

  • The Bakery Of Nightmares

    26.The Bakery Of Nightmares

    10-03-202635 min

    Why would you do this to sweet treats :(

  • There's Drama In Recipe Comments

    27.There's Drama In Recipe Comments

    14-04-202642 min

    Do you think there is a tea recipe with tea in the comments?

  • Mom Says Dinner’s Ready!

    28.Mom Says Dinner’s Ready!

    16-06-202635 min

    Come downstairs, dinner is ready!!

Watching Lists

to create and edit public lists.

Loading lists…

Purchase & Discovery

Find this title on Amazon

Digital

Prime Video & digital

Amazon mixes rent, buy, and Prime in one place — one search covers the usual options.

As an Amazon Associate, Critic, Sir! earns from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure